Ladies, sign up now for The Crossing's Ladies Retreat in Ocean City from February 11-13, 2027. Register by December 20, 2026. Click to learn more.
When Witnessing Is Questioned | Acts 11:1–18

What do you do when someone questions your faith, criticizes a decision you made because of Jesus, or makes you feel like you need to defend every part of your life? Many people know that tension. A family member may ask why faith has to affect everything. A coworker may challenge why you brought up Jesus. A friend may pull away because your convictions have changed. In those moments, anxiety can rise quickly. It is easy to become defensive, go quiet, or replay the conversation long after it ends.
In When Witnessing Is Questioned, part of The Crossing’s Acts series, Adam Woods looks at Acts 11:1–18 and Peter’s response after believers in Jerusalem questioned his actions. Peter had shared the gospel with Cornelius and his household, Gentiles who received the Holy Spirit and the offer of salvation through Jesus. Instead of reacting in anger, Peter listened to their concern, explained what happened, and trusted God to change hearts. This is a Bible teaching on responding to criticism, speaking about Jesus with grace, and trusting God when others do not understand your faith.
In this message we see that being a faithful witness includes both a life that reflects Jesus and words that explain the hope we have in Him. Christians are called to be prepared to give a reason for their hope, “with gentleness and respect” (1 Peter 3:15, NIV). That matters when relationships feel strained, when fear keeps someone from sharing faith, or when the approval of other people begins to shape identity.
For someone exploring Jesus, the invitation is to see that the gospel is for you, too. Jesus offers forgiveness, new life, and a place in God’s family. Turn from sin, trust in Christ, and consider baptism into Him. For believers, take one faithful step this week. Listen carefully to someone who has questions, explain your faith honestly, and trust God with what happens next. Your job is not to control the response. Your calling is to follow Jesus faithfully.
Sharing faith can create tension because following Jesus shapes real decisions, relationships, and values. In Acts 11, Peter was questioned after he shared the gospel with Gentiles. Adam Woods explains that tension does not automatically mean a believer has done something wrong. It can be an opportunity to listen carefully, explain what happened truthfully, and trust God with the response.
Start by listening instead of preparing a quick defense. James 1:19 says believers should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry. Adam Woods points out that listening does not mean agreeing with every criticism. It means seeking to understand, remaining humble, and being willing to receive correction if needed.
A life of integrity and kindness matters because it can open doors for spiritual conversations. But Adam Woods teaches that example alone is not the full witness. People also need to hear the good news that Jesus died for sin, rose from the dead, and offers forgiveness and new life through His name.
You do not need to have a perfect answer for every question in order to be a faithful witness. Peter simply explained what God had done and pointed people back to the words of Jesus. The Crossing encourages believers to speak honestly, admit when they are still learning, and trust the Holy Spirit to help them share the hope they have with gentleness and respect.
Remember that your identity is not built on other people’s approval. In Christ, you are loved by God and called His child. Adam Woods explains that this security helps believers listen without fear, admit mistakes when needed, and remain faithful even when a relationship feels strained or a conversation remains unresolved.
SERMON: ACTS
WHEN WITNESSING IS QUESTIONED
Act 11:1-18
Turn in your Bibles to Acts 11 [p ], we’re going to be looking at the first 18 verses today. Acts 11.
Have you ever done something you believed was right and then found yourself having to explain it to someone you thought would understand?
-You brought up church at dinner and a family member asked, “Why do you have to bring religion into everything?”
-You explained how your faith shapes a decision at work, and someone said, “Can’t you keep your beliefs to yourself?”
-You invited someone over who needed a friend and someone from church asks, “Why are you hanging out with them?”
You expected understanding…but instead you found yourself defending your decision. Today—we’re back with Peter in Acts 11—and that’s exactly what he’s facing.
Last week in Acts 10, we watched him walk into Cornelius’ home and tell a room full of Gentiles about Jesus. Peter learned that God’s offer of salvation through Jesus included them, too.
Today, we follow Peter home. He has obeyed God—but the believers in Jerusalem haven’t yet heard the whole story. And they have questions about what he’s done.
You see, obeying God doesn’t mean everyone will understand. Sometimes even people we love will question what we’re doing. And that can hurt.
You were trying to be faithful. You were trying to love someone. You finally found the courage to speak about Jesus—and now you’re facing questions you weren’t expecting.
When that happens, it’s easy to get defensive. Or angry. Or start second-guessing yourself. You may even think, If this is what happens when I speak up, I’ll just keep my mouth shut.
The way Peter responds in our text today is gonna help us.
Here’s the question he’s gonna help us with: How do we respond to criticism in a way that honors God and keeps us faithful to the mission He’s called us to?
We’ll look at three steps: Listen well. Speak the Truth. Trust God.
READ Acts 11:1-3
The news had reached Jerusalem. The Gentiles had received God’s Word. But when Peter arrives, some of the believers there—his own friends and neighbors—criticize him.
This is where Step 1 is critical: LISTEN WELL. When you're criticized, who you're questioned about something yo did—LISTEN WELL.
Their concern is specific: “You went into a Gentile's home and ate with them.”
In their defense, sharing a table meant acceptance and friendship. For Peter and his companions to eat in a Gentile home, was at the very least shocking and at most, sinful in the eyes of these Jewish believers. From their perspective, Peter had crossed a boundary they always understood God’s people should avoid.
Now, we know what happened in Cornelius’ house, but these believers didn’t. There weren’t there. They had questions. And Peter would need to address them.
What happens inside you when someone questions something you’ve done?
For most of us, we be bristle up, right? Our defenses go up fast. Before the person even finishes talking, we’ve already prepared our rebuttal.
We’re hearing their words, but we’re also having another conversation inside our heads: “They don’t understand.”
“They always do this.” “I know exactly what I’m gonna say.”
Sometimes we even respond to an accusation they never make.
Church, understand: A defensive response can make it harder for someone to hear the truth we want to share.
Remember what James teaches us? My dear brothers and sisters, take note of this: Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry, because human anger does not produce the righteousness that God desires. [James 1:19-20]
That’s good instruction for the moment when you feel misunderstood or attacked. Before you answer, take the time to LISTEN WELL—make sure you understand where they’re coming from.
A simple line that helps me, “Hey, help me understand what concerns you.”
Maybe they don’t have all the information. Maybe they misunderstood. Maybe they’ve noticed something you need to know about. You won’t know if you don’t listen.
Listening doesn’t mean you agree with every criticism. It means you’re willing to understand it—and humble enough to consider whether you need correction.
Peter himself had needed correction before, right? Before he walked into Cornelius’ house, God challenged the way he saw people.
Being questioned or criticized doesn’t automatically mean you’re wrong…it doesn’t automatically mean you’re right either.
So when criticism comes—LISTEN WELL.
Luke doesn’t tell us everything Peter felt, but he shows us Peter’s first move: he listens to their concern and then explains.
And that's...
Step 2—SPEAK THE TRUTH
v4 says [READ Acts 11:4]. Peter explains what happened—from the beginning—and what follows is a straight up—almost verbatim retelling—of what we read in Acts 10 last week.
In v5-10, he tells them about the vision—the sheet, the animals, the command to eat. And he also includes his own objection when God commands him to kill and eat: Surely not, Lord!
Peter hadn’t understood it all from the start. God had to correct him. Peter could’ve left that part out and made himself look like he had it figured out. He doesn’t. He speaks the truth about himself, too.
Sometimes we tell a story in a way that makes us look a little better. We leave out our uncertainty. We skip over what we got wrong. We make it sound like we knew exactly what God was doing all along.
Can we do what Peter did? Can we say, I understand why you have questions. I had questions too? Or when it’s needed, Here’s where I got it wrong?
Listen, we can explain our convictions honestly and still acknowledge that we’re growing. Then Peter explains what happens next in v11-14.
The men arrive. The Spirit tells him to go with them. Six other believers go along, and they enter Cornelius’ house.
Notice how directly Peter addresses the criticism.
They criticized and said, You went into their house.
Peter says, in effect, Yes we did…and here’s why.
He points to the Holy Spirit’s instruction, to the brothers who were with him, and to what Cornelius had been told. He gives them reasons they needed to hear and should consider before they land on a conclusion.
Sometimes people question our actions because they don’t know what led to them. So…help them understand—SPEAK THE TRUTH.
Suppose a coworker says: Why did you bring up Jesus with that new guy on the team? You might answer: He told me that he was going through a hard time and asked what helps me when life feels heavy. I listened, and then told them about the hope I have in Jesus.
Explain what happened. Explain why you acted. And bring your convictions back to Scripture and to the clear call Jesus has given us as His followers: we are to be His witnesses.
Here’s something I hear a lot: I’m more of a lead-by-example kinda person.
I love that! Your consistent life matters. The way you show up for people, your integrity at work, the way you care for your family and help others—those things open doors. Keep doing them.
But example alone is not the full witness.
Let me give you a real-life picture. A guy in our church—we'll call him George—worked on a construction crew for years. He was known as the guy who never cut corners, who stayed late to help a teammate finish, who brought extra water on hot days. People respected him.
One afternoon, a younger guy on the crew finally said, “George, you’re different from everybody else out here. What’s the deal?”
George could’ve just smiled and said, “I’m just trying to be a good person.”
Instead, he said, “It’s Jesus. He’s changed everything for me. Can I tell you about that?”
That conversation led to the younger guy coming to church, and a few months later he was baptized into Christ.
George’s life opened the door. His words walked the guy through it.
You see, being a witness includes both the life and the words. People can appreciate your kindness without ever understanding the hope behind it. They still need someone to put the good news into words: that Jesus died for our sins, that God raised Him from the dead, and that forgiveness is offered through His name.
That’s the message Peter brought into Cornelius’ home last week.
Later in his life, Peter would give instruction to the church—that may have been rooted in this moment in Acts 11.
In 1 Peter 3 he wrote, In your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect, keeping a clear conscience, so that those who speak maliciously against your good behavior in Christ [those who criticize you…] may be ashamed of their slander. [1 Peter 3:15-16]
The point isn't sticking it to someone. The point is: be prepared to explain the hope you have in Jesus and do it with gentleness and respect. Because the truth we speak matters…and so does the way we speak it.
In v15-16, Peter finishes his explanation by describing the Holy Spirit coming on the Gentiles, just as He had on the disciples at the beginning.
Then, Peter says (this is v16), I remembered what the Lord had said. [Acts 11:16]
Don’t miss that.
Jesus’ words helped Peter understand what God was doing. And God’s Word must guide our understanding, too.
When your witness is questioned, SPEAK THE TRUTH—about what happened, about what you learned, and about Jesus. We have the message of how to be saved. So don’t leave it in your pocket this week.
SPEAK UP. Don’t wait until you feel completely ready or until the moment feels perfect. Jesus said that when you're willing to speak up, the Holy Spirit will give you the words to say.
That's the same Spirit who sent Peter to Cornelius. He's with you too. Open your mouth. SPEAK THE TRUTH about Jesus. Some people around you will never hear it if you don’t say it.
That’s brings us to Step 3—TRUST GOD
READ Acts 11:17-18
Peter brings his explanation to this conclusion: God gave the Gentile believers the same gift He gave us.
And he knew that refusing them would mean standing against what God had done. And he says as much: Who was I to think that I could stand in God’s way?
That explains why he acted the way he did. God had directed him. God had confirmed what was happening. Peter needed to obey.
Now—facing criticism—he explains that obedience. And he explains himself with confidence, not defensiveness. His confidence rests in God’s direction, even while others have questions. And we need that same confidence.
Once we’ve listened, considered correction, and explained our convictions, there comes a point then, when we just need to entrust the rest to the Lord.
God is the One who changes people's hearts and minds. God is the One who saves. That takes the burden off our shoulders. Sometimes we think, if I don’t say it perfectly, or if I can’t answer every question—I’ve blown it. And then we clam up—we freeze.
Listen, you’re responsibility is to be a faithful witness—to love and listen and speak truthfully. Then TRUST GOD with the response.
You can’t make someone believe. You can’t make someone understand or approve of you. God is the One who changes people.
So an uncomfortable conversation doesn’t mean you blew it.
Ask yourself: Did I represent Jesus truthfully? Did I treat this person with gentleness and respect?
Then entrust their response to the Lord. You can keep loving them without carrying the burden of changing them.
In Acts 11, the believers hear Peter’s explanation and their objections stop. They praise God. That’s a wonderful outcome. We should pray for understanding like that.
But not every difficult conversation ends in agreement.
Sometimes people need time. Sometimes another conversation is necessary. Sometimes someone else helps bring understanding. And sometimes, they’ll continue to disagree—and the relationship will feel strained for a while.
And that hurts. It can cost you the closeness and influence and ease you once shared. The cost is real.
I think especially of some of you younger folks. You may lose the easy invitation to the group chat. You may notice the family group text goes quiet when you speak about Jesus. A friendship that used to feel effortless now feels like you're walking on eggshells. A parent or sibling may look at you differently. Following Jesus can put real pressure on the relationships you care about most.
Hear me: the cost does not mean you did it wrong. It means the gospel is costly. Jesus told us it would be. And He is still worth it. You can remain gracious and faithful while the conversation remains unresolved.
You don’t have to keep repeating yourself until they approve. You don’t have to compromise your convictions just to relieve the tension. And you don’t have to replay the conversation all night trying to find the perfect sentence that would have fixed everything.
If you need to apologize, apologize. If you need to clarify, clarify. Then TRUST GOD to do what only He can do.
CONCLUSION
So, when criticism comes or our witness is questioned, we LISTEN WELL, we SPEAK THE TRUTH, and we TRUST GOD with what happens.
Now, those steps are easy to remember…but they can be hard to take.
When I feel misunderstood, I want to defend myself. When someone challenges me, I want to prove my point. When I can’t control how someone responds, I get frustrated. And sometimes I want to avoid the next conversation all together. Anyone else feel that?
So what would help us take those steps? I think the key is remembering who we are in Christ.
Hear me out: sometimes criticism hurts so deeply because we’ve started depending on someone’s approval to tell us who we are...to affirm that we’re okay. But remembering who we are in Christ anchors us—and their approval doesn’t determine our worth.
Listen to Ephesians 2:10—We are God’s masterpiece, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.
Or Colossians 3:1-3 Since, then, you have been raised with Christ, set your hearts on things above, where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God. Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things. For you died, and your life is now hidden with Christ in God.
Or 1 John 3:1 See what great love the Father has lavished on us, that we should be called children of God! And that is what we are!
If you are in Christ today—you are God’s masterpiece…you have been raised with Christ, your life hidden with Him in God…He calls you His children—and that is what you are!
Your identity in Christ is the ground under your feet when the conversation gets hard. You don’t have to earn God’s love by handling every criticism perfectly. You already have it in Christ.
Because of that, you can admit when you’re wrong. You can listen without treating every question as a threat. You can speak honestly about how you acted. And you can keep obeying even when someone’s approval doesn’t come.
Their criticism may hurt, but it doesn’t have to decide your next step. Let Jesus shape that step.
I’m wondering if any of you have been thinking back to a recent conversation that felt like the one we’re talking about today—one where someone questioned your faith or something you did.
Maybe you became defensive. Maybe you’ve gone quiet. Or maybe you’ve been rehearsing what you’re going to say next, instead of listening.
This week: take a step toward that person. Ask them to help you understand what’s concerning them. Take some time to explain your actions more clearly. Apologize if you need to. And if you’ve already done those things, pray for that person and entrust the whole thing to the Lord.
If you're on the other side where fear of criticism has kept you from speaking at all, acknowledge that fear and take a step toward a conversation about Jesus. Trusting God may mean speaking again, even when the last conversation was uncomfortable. It can be as simple as, “The reason I live the way I do is because of Jesus.
Crossing family, hear me:
Because we are loved by God, we can LISTEN WELL.
Because His message has been entrusted to us, we can SPEAK THE TRUTH. And because He is Lord of all, we can TRUST GOD for whatever happens next.
So, when your witness is questioned or the our actions are criticized, remember who you belong to —and keep taking the next faithful step on the mission—because the world needs the hope we have in Jesus.
PRAY

